Skip to main content

Tickets

Home

Main navigation

  • Worship and music
  • Visit us
  • What's on
  • Safeguarding
  • Search

Secondary navigation

  • Search
  • Visit us
    • Book tickets
    • Plan your visit
      • How to find us
      • Guided and self-guided tours
      • Visit with your family
      • Accessibility at the Cathedral
      • Group visits
      • UK schools visits
      • Remember Me Memorial
      • Filming and photography
      • Safety and security
    • Explore our map
    • Information for travel trade
    • Booking tickets FAQ
  • What's on
  • Worship and music
    • Music
      • Upcoming performances
      • Our choirs
      • Our musicians
      • Working with schools
      • Information for visiting choirs
      • The bells
      • The organ
    • Worship with us
      • Our services
      • Attending a St Paul's service
      • Join your London community
      • Weddings, baptisms and confirmations
  • History and collections
    • Explore our stories and collections
      • Hidden histories
      • Architecture and decoration
      • Celebration and remembrance
      • Exploring faith through art
      • Library treasures
    • A timeline of the Cathedral
    • About our Collections
    • Access the Collections
    • Conservation
    • Our podcast series
    • The East India Company at St Paul's
    • War and resistance in the Caribbean: The monuments at St Paul's
  • St Paul's Cathedral Institute
  • Learning
    • Visit with your UK school
    • Our digital resources
  • About us
    • Our mission and purpose
    • Who we are
    • News and updates
    • Our annual reports and accounts
    • Contact us
    • Work for us
    • Press and media
    • St Paul's Cathedral in America
  • Support us
    • Donate to us
    • Become a Friend
    • Become a Music Patron
    • Leave a legacy
    • Volunteer with us
    • Corporate support
    • Trusts and foundations
  • Your event at St Paul's
    • Event space guide
    • Explore our venues
      • Wren Suite
      • The Crypt
      • Chapter House
      • Nelson Chamber
      • North Churchyard
    • Our approved suppliers
    • Weddings, baptisms and confirmations
  • Shop
Menu Close
Filter

Suggested searches:

  • Book sightseeing tickets
  • Family activities
  • Saving St Paul's exhibition
  • Wren 300
  • Map of the Cathedral
  • Opening times
  • Service schedule

Secondary navigation

  • Search
  • Visit us
    • Book tickets
    • Plan your visit
      • How to find us
      • Guided and self-guided tours
      • Visit with your family
      • Accessibility at the Cathedral
      • Group visits
      • UK schools visits
      • Remember Me Memorial
      • Filming and photography
      • Safety and security
    • Explore our map
    • Information for travel trade
    • Booking tickets FAQ
  • What's on
  • Worship and music
    • Music
      • Upcoming performances
      • Our choirs
      • Our musicians
      • Working with schools
      • Information for visiting choirs
      • The bells
      • The organ
    • Worship with us
      • Our services
      • Attending a St Paul's service
      • Join your London community
      • Weddings, baptisms and confirmations
  • History and collections
    • Explore our stories and collections
      • Hidden histories
      • Architecture and decoration
      • Celebration and remembrance
      • Exploring faith through art
      • Library treasures
    • A timeline of the Cathedral
    • About our Collections
    • Access the Collections
    • Conservation
    • Our podcast series
    • The East India Company at St Paul's
    • War and resistance in the Caribbean: The monuments at St Paul's
  • St Paul's Cathedral Institute
  • Learning
    • Visit with your UK school
    • Our digital resources
  • About us
    • Our mission and purpose
    • Who we are
    • News and updates
    • Our annual reports and accounts
    • Contact us
    • Work for us
    • Press and media
    • St Paul's Cathedral in America
  • Support us
    • Donate to us
    • Become a Friend
    • Become a Music Patron
    • Leave a legacy
    • Volunteer with us
    • Corporate support
    • Trusts and foundations
  • Your event at St Paul's
    • Event space guide
    • Explore our venues
      • Wren Suite
      • The Crypt
      • Chapter House
      • Nelson Chamber
      • North Churchyard
    • Our approved suppliers
    • Weddings, baptisms and confirmations
  • Shop
Explore our site

Exhibition: Saving St Paul's: The Watch and the Second World War

a silhouette of a male figure wearing a hat against a background of St Paul's bell tower

Exhibition: Saving St Paul's: The Watch and the Second World War

Worship with us

couple reading service schedule during consecration service

Worship with us

Ways to donate

choristers boys sharing candle light christmas

Ways to donate

Our digital resources

Rowan Williams smiling as he leafs through his book at an event at St Paul's Cathedral

Our digital resources

Stories from St Paul's podcast

library books dark

Stories from St Paul's podcast

Faith and Politics

Visit our learning library
Written reflection
Justice
Politics
Adults

Faith and Politics

Graeme Smith reflects on Christians' involvement in politics.

1. Guiding Principles

It is reported that when news spread that the well-loved Archbishop, William Temple, had died prematurely in 1944, people on trams had tears in their eyes. 

Temple’s most famous book is Christianity and Social Order, in which he discussed why, and how, Christians should be involved in politics. The question of involvement was a relatively new one, in part provoked by the emerging phenomenon of secularism which Temple had learnt about at the Jerusalem 1928 International Missionary Conference. What has endured from Temple’s book is not so much his rationale for engagement, that argument is largely over, but the more vexed question of how should Christians be involved. 

Temple argued Christians who are well-versed in theology are not thereby equipped to comment on what might be appropriate housing policy or education reform. That should be left to the non-theological domain of detailed political policy, which is the preserve of party politicians. 

What Christians can do is offer guiding principles or values which should be taken into account by politicians when they are deciding on policies. Temple called these ‘middle axioms’ and he listed relevant ones in an appendix. 

Versions of Temple’s middle axioms approach have informed much Church of England political theology ever since, a prime example being the controversial Faith in the City report in 1985. They also inform the appeal of single issue campaign groups, over political parties, for most socially and politically concerned Christians. There are however two problems with the approach. First there is no good reason why politicians should listen to theologians, and so usually they don’t. Second it adopts the Modernist assumption that there is a Christian theological world and a separate secular political world. As we go on to see this assumption is increasingly in doubt as what we thought we knew about secularism is called into question.

2. Personal Values

The UK religious landscape is not as straightforwardly secular as we once thought. 

There is no doubt that the institutional Christian churches are in trouble. The numbers of those attending have been declining significantly. Fewer people get married, have their children baptised or have funerals in church. Christian festivals are treated as secular holidays and the numbers offering for ministry are declining. There are always pockets which buck the trend but the overall picture is bleak and it is no surprise that the Church of England is focusing its resources on increasing membership. 

To say that secularism is not as straightforwardly ascendant as was once thought is not to say this picture is inaccurate. However it is not the whole picture. Grace Davie has captured the ambiguity with her idea ‘believing without belonging’. 

We live in an increasingly fragmented society in which people do not belong to clubs and societies in the ways they once did. Political parties suffer poor attendance at meetings. But this does not mean that people no longer subscribe to the beliefs of an organisation. 

People may not go to church, but they do still believe in God. When Tony Blair stated that he believed in God it chimed with 80% of his constituency, according to the 2001 Census. These numbers have declined since then, it seems not belonging has consequences for believing, but Christianity is still influential in UK politics. 

The question is how? Blair’s answer was through personal values, an answer remarkably similar to William Temple’s ‘middle axioms’ which we explored previously. Blair’s values came from his faith, and these values shaped and informed the policy decisions he made. It is a Modernist answer in that it assumes belief is a private matter which forms the attitudes and behaviour of the individual. Beliefs act as motivation for political choices. It is close to the idea of ‘the end justifying the means’. 

The challenge of a re-thought secularism is that this division is not as clear cut as Blair might think. We’ll think further about this next time.

3. Ethical Codes

Margaret Thatcher saw her Christianity and her politics as two sides of the same coin. 

Famously she was raised a Methodist, the daughter of a shopkeeper, alderman and lay preacher. She was formed by an identity which believed faithful Christian discipleship consisted of hard work, thrift, personal responsibility (especially saving for a rainy day), family care and charity. 

We can call this a Protestant Non-Conformity and it shapes her religious, political and personal identity. This identity shaped her hatred of the Soviet Union and her dislike of the European Union. The latter was fine when it provided opportunities for entrepreneurs through the single market, but morally dangerous when it removed from people the requirement to be responsible, delegating that to the State. It might be thought that these notions of thrift, personal responsibility and charity were her values in much the same way as Tony Blair. However this is to miss the depth with which they shaped all aspects of her life, personal and political. They formed the ethical code by which she lived, and judged others. To extend the power of the State, in ways the Faith in the City report proposed, was not just bad politics, it was morally wrong. 

Thatcher was, in her own words, engaged in a spiritual revolution which would bring back pride and prosperity. And it was a message which chimed with a majority of people in the UK. 

It has produced a political ethos which remains dominant in our political culture. Politicians on the Left, as well as the Right, talk about the need to help ‘hard-working families’. Public finances cannot support a welfare State or educational provision that ‘we cannot afford’. The question is, if this political culture is so dominant, how are there people on the Left who argue the State should do more?

4. Common Good

If Protestant Non-Conformity is the dominant identity in UK politics then why are there so many on the Left who oppose it, including many clergy? 

The answer is straightforward. It is dominant but it is not exclusive. There is at least one other identity, something that can be called a Catholic Common Good identity. 

The ideas that underpin this identity are determinist, people who are poor or oppressed are so usually because of circumstances well beyond their control. Poor people have fewer opportunities to succeed because of the impact of their poverty on their education and health. Poverty is a generational vicious circle. So, to bring about change, to achieve justice, the State must intervene. State intervention is not a moral evil but the only way to achieve moral good. 

In this way of thinking, Protestant Non-Conformity is regarded as at best ignorant and at worst deliberately ethically cruel. As far as Catholic Common Good advocates are concerned, Protestant Non-Conformists are privileged, selfish and exploitative. 

All of which means we have two competing ethical codes both grounded in our Christian heritage. For one to regard the other as immoral is to fail to understand its Christian heritage and ethical identity. But what is to be done if these two sides are not merely to shout at each other? 

My view is that Protestant Non-Conformity is dominant in the UK and any politics of the Left - of Catholic Common Good - needs to accommodate with the responsible individualism it advocates. This means finding ways to combine the rhetoric of hard work, thrift, charity and personal responsibility with the rhetoric of State intervention. This will look like a type of social or radical individualism. It is what New Labour looked for, as does Starmer. It will earn him the critique of the Left. However it is the most radical option open to him, given our dominant Christian ethical culture.

Graeme is a white man with short grey hair and a black top, seated in front of a white wall with a white framed photo behind him.
Professor Graeme Smith is the Programme Leader for the MA in Theology, Imagination and Culture at Sarum College, Salisbury.

Also in this theme

Catherine Okoronkwo is a black woman with shoulder length braided hair, wearing a short sleeved black top with a clerical collar. She stands in the Cathedral high up on the triforium level, with the nave of the Cathedral behind her.
Sermon

MLK Anniversary Choral Evensong Sermon Dec 2024

Sermon to mark the 60th Anniversary of Dr Martin Luther King Jr preaching at St Paul's Cathedral. The Reverend Dr Catherine Okoronkwo, Canon Steward, at Choral Evensong , on 8th December 2024.
Find out more
Raphael Warnock, a black man with bald head and glasses wearing a dark suit and blue striped tie, stands a t a lectern on stage in St Paul's Cathedral, the pulpit and quire in the background
Film and video

Revd Raphael Warnock speaks at St Paul's Cathedral on Martin Luther King's legacy

On the 60th anniversary of Martin Luther King's historic visit to St Paul's Cathedral, The Revd Raphael Warnock reflects on what he has to say to us today. The talk was entitled ''Three Dimensions of a Complete Life: Martin Luther King for this moment'.
Find out more
Selina Stone is a young black woman and is pictured at the lectern in the Wren Suite, an exposed brick wall behind her.
Film and video

How Long O Lord? Prayer and Justice

Selina Stone reflects on the relationship of prayer, justice and a transformed world.
Find out more

Our address

St Paul's Cathedral
St Paul's Churchyard
London
EC4M 8AD

View on map
How to find us

Footer Column 2

  • Visit us
    • Book sightseeing tickets
    • Explore our map
    • Plan your visit
    • Accessibility
    • Remember Me COVID-19 Memorial
    • Travel trade
  • What's on
    • Search our events
  • History and collections
    • Explore our stories and collections
    • Timeline of the Cathedral
    • 70 Years of the Friends
    • About our Collections
    • Access the Collections
    • Conservation
    • Our podcast series
    • Visit the catalogue

Footer Column 3

  • Worship and music
    • Worship with us
    • Music
  • Learning
    • Our digital resources
    • Visit with your UK school
  • About us
    • Our mission and purpose
    • Who we are
    • Annual reports and accounts
    • News and updates
    • Contact us
    • Work for us
    • Press and media
    • Statement of investment principles
  • St Paul's Cathedral Institute

Footer Column 4

  • Support us
    • Donate to us
    • Become a Friend
    • Become a Music Patron
    • Leave a legacy
    • Volunteer with us
    • Trusts and foundations
    • Corporate support
  • Your event at St Paul's
    • Corporate hospitality
    • Wren Suite
    • Chapter House
    • Nelson Chamber
    • North Churchyard
    • The Crypt
    • Weddings, baptisms and confirmations
  • Shop

Utility links

  • Terms and conditions of entry
  • Privacy policy
  • Staff and volunteers portal
  • Terms of use

Safeguarding

St Paul's Cathedral takes safeguarding very seriously. We are committed to protecting the welfare of children and of all adults who are vulnerable – whether that be our worshippers, visitors, clergy, staff or volunteers.

Find out more

rgb(143,63,109)

Copyright St Paul’s Cathedral 2025

Registered charity number: 1206171